KARACHI – Aug 27: Speakers at the launch of the 9th report on “The State of Peasants’ Rights in Sindh” for 2023 demanded to amend and implement the Sindh Tenancy Act for the protection of peasants’ rights in the province.

Member, National Commission for Human Rights Ms. Anis Harion; Chairman, Sindh Human Rights Commission Iqbal Detho; Dean Faculty of Social Sciences SZABIST Dr. Riaz Sheikh; senior trade union leader Habibuddin Junaidi; women rights activist Ms. Mahnaz Rahman; senior journalist Sohail Sangi; General Secretary, Pakistan Fisherfolk Forum Saeed Baloch; senior journalist and researcher Ishak Soomro, Vice Chairman of Human Rights Commission of Pakistan Kazi Khizar and others spoke on the occasion.

The speakers voiced their deep concern over the persistent and widespread practice of debt bondage, despite the enactment of the Sindh Bonded Labour Abolition Act of 2015. The District Vigilance Committees (DVCs), established under the Act in every district, have failed to play a significant role in rescuing, protecting, and rehabilitating bonded labourers. Their lack of effectiveness remains a pressing issue.

Ms Anis Haroon paid tributes to Hari leader Haider Bux Jatoi and others and said that peasants in Sindh still suffer due to influential landlords.

Iqbal Detho pointed out that the SHRC has taken up many workers’ issues including the implementation of the Minimum Wages law.

Akram Ali Khaskheli, President of the Hari Welfare Association pointed out that in 2023, the data gathered by his association indicated that 542 peasants were liberated from bonded labour in the agriculture sector, including 185 children, 178 women, and 179 men.

Additionally, between 2013 and 2023, a total of 12,116 bonded labourers were freed from the clutches of landlords in Sindh, including 4,134 children and 4,037 women.

Khaskheli criticized the Sindh government for its anti-peasant stance, particularly its refusal to withdraw an appeal filed in the Supreme Court of Pakistan against a pivotal ruling by the Sindh High Court (SHC) in October 2019. This appeal challenges the nullification of regressive amendments to tenancy laws and the issues surrounding bonded labour, reflecting the government’s support for the entrenched feudal and tribal systems that hinder the establishment of a just legal framework for peasants.

He said the Sindh Women Agriculture Workers Act of 2019, despite receiving international recognition, has not been implemented even after five years of passage as no women’s groups have been formed under this law. Additionally, the Sindh Industrial Relations Act (SIRA) of 2015, which acknowledges peasants as workers and grants them the right to form unions, has not had its Rules of Business officially notified. This lack of clarity in defining the rights and scope of agricultural workers further complicates the legal landscape.

Khaskheli also noted that the recently approved Sindh Water Policy (SWP), which aims to manage water resources effectively, faces implementation challenges due to bureaucratic inertia and inadequate funding. These challenges threaten to undermine its effectiveness, particularly for peasants and rural workers.

The report highlights that the Sindh government pledged to introduce ‘Hari Cards’ for underprivileged peasants with a subsidy of Rs. 3 billion. However, the HWA expressed concerns about the lack of groundwork, inadequate documentation, and the exclusion of landless sharecropping peasants from this program. The press release also noted that on November 2, 2023, the Sindh Labour and Human Resource Department announced a minimum wage of Rs. 32,000 per month for unskilled workers. However, this wage remains unimplemented in rural areas, where daily wages for male workers average around Rs. 700, with female workers earning even less.

The report has recommended that the Sindh government must immediately withdraw its appeal against the Sindh High Court’s 2019 ruling to demonstrate support for progressive tenancy laws and the eradication of bonded labour, in alignment with the Constitution of Pakistan and international agreements.

The Sindh Tenancy Act (STA) provisions, particularly the requirement for written tenancy agreements, must be actively enforced to prevent disputes and protect peasants’ rights. The Sindh Resettlement and Rehabilitation Policy (2022) should also be amended to include specific measures for land redistribution and livelihood restoration for landless peasants, especially those affected by natural disasters.

Furthermore, the government should allocate necessary funding and provide technical assistance to activate and enhance the effectiveness of DVCs across Sindh and ensure that the Rules of Business for the Sindh Bonded Labour Abolition Act are framed in consultation with civil society organizations and published in the gazette as soon as possible.

The HWA also demanded that the government implement strict measures to prevent forced evictions, the demolition of huts, and the seizure of livestock, ensuring that any eviction processes respect the rights and dignity of the affected families. Additionally, the benefits of the Hari Card program should be extended to include landless sharecropping peasants, with all necessary documentation and groundwork completed for effective implementation. Lastly, the government must monitor and enforce the recently notified minimum wage rates across all rural areas and implement measures to address wage disparities, particularly for female workers.